How to Sell a Used Gun in New Jersey | Legal Step-By-Step Guide

Online   Aug 21, 2025

 

Thinking about selling a firearm in New Jersey? Whether you inherited a collection, need to downsize, or simply want to sell a single firearm, it’s important to understand that New Jersey has some of the strictest gun laws in the country.

This guide will walk you through the legal, step-by-step process of selling your used gun in New Jersey—and show you how Middlebrook Firearms makes the process simple, safe, and compliant.

 

Step 1: Know the Legal Requirements

In New Jersey, all firearm sales—whether private or through a dealer—must go through a federally licensed firearms dealer (FFL). That means:

• No cash “hand-to-hand” private sales.

• Transfers must include a background check through the NJ NICS system.

• Proper paperwork is required to complete the sale legally.

⚠️ Skipping these steps can result in serious legal consequences, including fines or charges.

 

Step 2: Decide How You Want to Sell

You generally have two legal options when selling your used gun in New Jersey:

1. Sell through an FFL (Gun Shop):

   - The safest, most straightforward route.

   - The FFL handles background checks, paperwork, and transfer records.

   - Many shops, like Middlebrook Firearms, offer cash offers for used firearms.

2. Transfer to a Private Buyer (Through an FFL):

   - If you already have a buyer, you’ll still need to complete the transfer at an FFL.

   - Both parties must appear, provide ID, and complete the necessary forms.

 

Step 3: Gather Your Firearm Information

Before you head to an FFL:

• Write down the make, model, and serial number of the firearm.

• Gather any accessories, cases, or documentation that may increase its value.

• If you’re selling an estate collection, organize the firearms for easier evaluation.

 

Step 4: Complete the Transfer Through an FFL

At the gun shop, the process looks like this:

1. You present the firearm and your ID.

2. The FFL records the firearm in their bound book.

3. The buyer (or shop) completes paperwork and background checks.

4. Once approved, ownership is legally transferred.

This ensures you’re no longer liable for the firearm and that everything is properly documented.

Step 5: Get Paid (Safely & Legally)

If you’re selling directly to a gun shop:

• You’ll receive a cash offer or check once the paperwork is complete.

• No need to worry about meeting strangers or handling risky transactions.

If you’re transferring to a private buyer:

• Agree on payment terms beforehand.

• The transfer must still occur at the FFL before the firearm changes hands.

 

Why Choose Middlebrook Firearms?

At Middlebrook Firearms (NJGunShop.com) in Green Brook, NJ, we make the process simple:

✅ Cash Offers for used firearms and collections.

✅ All Legal Paperwork Handled by our experienced team.

✅ Safe, Discreet, and Local — no risky online deals or unverified buyers.

✅ Trusted by NJ Gun Owners — family-owned and community-focused.

 

Conclusion

Selling your used gun in New Jersey doesn’t have to be complicated—as long as you follow the rules. By working with a trusted NJ FFL like Middlebrook Firearms, you can be confident your sale is legal, safe, and stress-free.